reSee.it - Related Video Feed

Chloe Cole, an 18-year-old detransitioner, began her medical transition at age 12, experiencing gender dysphoria and undergoing therapy. She started puberty blockers at 13, testosterone at 14, and had a double mastectomy at 15. Chloe now advocates against gender ideology and seeks legal accountability for the medical professionals involved in her transition. Chloe's journey began with feelings of gender dysphoria and social difficulties, particularly in connecting with other girls. She felt more comfortable with boys and struggled with body image issues, exacerbated by social media's portrayal of femininity. Despite early puberty, she felt disconnected from her female peers and sought validation through a male identity, believing it would alleviate her distress. During therapy, Chloe felt her concerns were not thoroughly explored. Instead, her therapists quickly affirmed her male identity without addressing underlying issues such as her autism diagnosis and social anxieties. Medical professionals presented transitioning as the only viable solution, often linking non-affirmation to suicide risk, which Chloe later identified as misleading. After starting testosterone, Chloe initially felt more confident but soon faced complications, including sexual dysfunction and urinary tract issues. The physical changes did not align with her expectations, leading to increased insecurities. Following her mastectomy, she experienced regret and a longing for her previous identity, realizing the importance of motherhood and the emotional connections tied to her female body. Chloe's turning point came during a psychology class, where she learned about maternal bonding and the significance of breastfeeding, prompting her to reconsider her transition. After reflecting on her experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic, she decided to stop her transition and began to express her regrets to her family. Chloe's legal action stems from the belief that she was not adequately informed about the consequences of her medical decisions. She emphasizes the need for comprehensive discussions about options and risks in therapy, particularly for minors. Chloe continues to deal with the physical and emotional repercussions of her transition, including ongoing health issues and a sense of loss regarding her identity and future. She has filed a letter of intent to sue her healthcare providers for the harm caused during her transition journey.

In the last decade, there has been a significant increase in teenage girls without prior gender dysphoria identifying as transgender, often influenced by peers and social media. Between 2016 and 2017, requests for gender surgeries among young women in the U.S. quadrupled. Abigail Shrier, author of *Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters*, discusses this alarming trend, emphasizing the lack of medical oversight in the current affirmative care model, which encourages doctors to affirm a teenager's self-diagnosis without thorough evaluation. Shrier highlights that many of these girls, often from supportive backgrounds, are experiencing mental health issues and find validation in transitioning. She argues that the current medical regime lacks safeguards, leading to potentially irreversible decisions made by young individuals. The influence of social media and the allure of being part of an oppressed minority contribute to this phenomenon. Parents, particularly those who are politically progressive, often feel helpless and fear losing custody if they question their child's decision to transition. Shrier notes that many parents are blindsided by the rapid changes in their children's identities and the aggressive push from activists and educators. The conversation around gender identity has become a cultural battleground, with significant implications for women's rights and the experiences of transgender individuals.

In this episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, Dr. Lisa Littman discusses her research on the surge of transgender identification among teenagers, particularly girls, which she terms "rapid onset gender dysphoria." Dr. Littman, a physician and researcher at Brown University, observed a statistically unusual increase in teenagers, especially girls, identifying as transgender and sought to study the phenomenon. Her findings suggest that social and peer influences may play a significant role in these identifications, leading to concerns about a potential social contagion effect. Dr. Littman faced significant backlash from trans activists and some members of the medical community, who accused her of bigotry and conducting shoddy science. Despite this, she received support from many parents who felt their children were being rushed into transitions without adequate evaluation. Her research indicated that many of the teenagers identifying as transgender had pre-existing mental health issues, raising questions about the underlying causes of their gender dysphoria. She emphasizes the importance of thorough evaluations before transitioning, noting that many detransitioners reported feeling pressured by healthcare providers to pursue medical interventions. Dr. Littman highlights the need for a balanced discussion about gender dysphoria, advocating for the inclusion of diverse experiences and cautioning against the oversimplification of the issue. The conversation also touches on the role of social media in shaping perceptions of gender identity among youth, with many parents reporting that their children were influenced by online communities. Dr. Littman calls for a more nuanced understanding of gender dysphoria that considers various factors, including mental health and social dynamics, rather than solely affirming a child's self-identification. She concludes by stressing the need for open dialogue and research to ensure that young people receive appropriate care and support.

Clementine Breen, a 22-year-old college student and detransitioner, shares her experience with gender transition and the subsequent challenges she faced. At 12, she received puberty blockers, began testosterone at 13, and underwent a double mastectomy at 14, all while feeling disconnected from her female peers and struggling with anxiety stemming from childhood sexual abuse. She did not disclose the abuse to her medical providers, who conducted minimal investigation into her history, leading to a swift diagnosis of gender dysphoria. Clementine highlights the role of Dr. Joanna Olsen Kennedy, a prominent figure in transgender youth healthcare, and Dr. Scott Mosser, her surgeon, in her treatment. She notes that Olsen Kennedy's research on gender-affirming care did not show improvements in mental health, yet the findings were not published to avoid political backlash. Clementine's experience reflects a broader concern about the lack of thorough psychological evaluation and the rush to affirm gender identities without addressing underlying issues like anxiety and depression. Throughout her transition, Clementine felt pressured by her guidance counselor and medical professionals to conform to a male identity, which initially provided her with social acceptance. However, as she continued her transition, she experienced severe mental health issues, including psychosis, which she attributes to both the testosterone and unresolved trauma from her past. After seeking therapy focused on her trauma, Clementine began to understand her identity differently and ultimately decided to detransition. She is now pursuing a lawsuit against the medical professionals involved in her care, aiming to raise awareness about the potential harms of gender-affirming treatments for youth. Clementine emphasizes the importance of addressing mental health issues before making irreversible medical decisions and encourages others to recognize that feelings of discomfort during puberty are common and do not necessarily indicate a need for medical intervention.

In a conversation between Joe Rogan and Abigail Shrier, they discuss Shrier's book, "Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters," which addresses the rising trend of teenage girls identifying as transgender. Shrier emphasizes that her concerns are not about adult transgender individuals, whom she supports, but rather about young girls who may be influenced by social media and peer groups to transition without fully understanding the implications. Shrier recounts how she became involved in this topic after hearing from parents whose daughters suddenly identified as transgender after experiencing mental health issues. She notes that many of these girls are high-achieving but socially isolated, leading them to seek identity through transitioning. Shrier highlights the alarming increase in teenage girls seeking hormone treatments and surgeries, citing a study by Lisa Littman that found a significant rise in such cases, particularly among friend groups. The discussion touches on the influence of social media, which Shrier argues exacerbates mental health issues among young girls, leading them to view transitioning as a solution to their problems. She points out that many girls who transition do not have a history of gender dysphoria and may be influenced by trends rather than genuine feelings of being in the wrong body. Rogan and Shrier also discuss the lack of medical oversight in the transitioning process, with Shrier noting that some clinics allow minors to access hormones without thorough psychological evaluation. They express concern about the long-term effects of hormone treatments and surgeries, particularly for those who may later regret their decisions. Shrier argues that the current approach to transgender issues often overlooks the complexities of adolescent mental health and the potential for social contagion, where young girls may adopt transgender identities as a response to peer dynamics. She calls for a more nuanced discussion that considers the mental health of these girls and the societal pressures they face. The conversation also addresses the backlash against those who question the prevailing narratives around transgender issues, with Shrier sharing her experiences of being criticized for her views. Both Rogan and Shrier emphasize the importance of open dialogue and the need to protect young people from making irreversible decisions without adequate support and information. Ultimately, Shrier advocates for a careful examination of the factors influencing young girls' decisions to transition and the potential consequences of those decisions, urging society to prioritize the mental health and well-being of these adolescents.