reSee.it Podcast Summary
Segal, an evolutionary psychologist and behavioral geneticist who specializes in studying twins, joins Dax Shepard and Monica Padman. She emphasizes that 'twins is really the only way we can learn about human behavior.' Segal discusses her books Entwined Lives, Born Together, Reared Apart, Accidental Brothers, and Deliberately Divided, and explains that twins provide a unique window into how genes and environment shape personality, ability, and life outcomes. In tracing the Minnesota study of twins raised apart and legendary pairs like the Jim Twins, she highlights how separated twins can resemble one another, illustrating genetic influence and environmental modulation. The conversation treats twins as a methodological lens on development rather than mere curiosities.
Early in the talk, she explains birth order effects: the firstborn is generally in better physical shape at delivery, while the second twin faces higher risk. She sums up a core claim: 'as long as they're raised in middle class homes with enough resources, parental attention, care, all that sort of thing, your genes will predispose you to a certain group of people, places, events, things that are compatible with who you are.' The idea is that genes predispose but do not determine, and extreme environments can modulate outcomes, especially in twins raised apart.
Segal details dramatic case studies that illuminate environment's reach. She describes British twins raised apart in different educational contexts and a Colombia case with 'virtual twins'—unrelated individuals sharing a home but with different genes—showing how environment and heredity diverge outcomes. She notes that extreme environmental differences can yield twins with similar scores on some measures yet differences on others. Her Minnesota twin study expanded to include fraternal twins, and she notes how look-alike unrelated individuals test differently, challenging assumptions that appearance predicts personality. Accidental Brothers (2018) documents these patterns and variations across geography and culture.
On theory, Segal anchors her discussion in evolutionary biology and kin selection. She cites Hamilton's kinship theory and inclusive fitness to explain altruism toward relatives and the surprising similarities twins can evoke in others. The conversation touches on doppelgangers as a research foil: 'doppelgangers are fascinating' and they often fail to show the personality correlation seen in twins raised apart. She also says 'twins are ideal for studying mate selection' and describes marriages among twins, highlighting how environment shapes intimate decisions and family structure. She emphasizes that 'differences are not deficits. Differences are just differences.'
Epigenetics enters as a frontier. She describes the epigenome as a fluid layer that modulates gene expression with birth factors and life experiences, producing discordant outcomes such as Alzheimer's or schizophrenia among genetically similar individuals. She cites the Janine quadruplets study to illustrate how early expectations clash with complex caregiving and biology. The discussion extends to cloning, IVF, and the ethics of creating genetically similar beings, with Segal arguing that the twin model remains a powerful framework for understanding behavior across contexts, not just among twins.