@julie_kelly2 - Julie Kelly 🇺🇸
More from Obama appointee Beryl Howell, who ordered the release of FBI documents responsive to a FOIA related to classified docs case.
FWIW, I am all for disclosing these documents. I believe the president recently declassified the files taken from Mar a Lago that Jack Smith claimed were "national defense information."
But Howell's self-serving and reckless commentary in nearly every order she issues is why she should be removed from the bench and why the public's trust in the judiciary is at an all time low.
Howell : "Of course, while the Supreme Court has provided a protective and presumptive immunity cloak for a president’s conduct, that cloak is not so large to extend to those who aid, abet and execute criminal acts on behalf of a criminally immune president."
[Howell's message here is--sure Trump was immune from prosecution but those around him were not. Like whom? And why is she assigning guilt to people around Trump, including his two co-defendants in this matter, when both indictments were dismissed including the docs case BEFORE Trump won.]
More Howell: "The excuse offered after World War II by enablers of the fascist Nazi regime of 'just following orders' has long been rejected in this country’s jurisprudence. See, e.g., United States v. North,(rejecting suggested instruction in criminal case that “goes so far as to conjure up the notion of a ‘Nuremberg’ defense, a notion from which our criminal justice system, one based on individual accountability and responsibility, has historically recoiled. …[W]e refuse to hold that following orders, without more, can transform an illegal act into a legal one.”), withdrawn and superseded in part on other grounds.
(“[O]ur criminal law does not recognize a ‘following orders’ or ‘Nuremberg’ defense.”).
(“[S]ince World War II, the ‘just following orders’ defense has not occupied a respected position in our jurisprudence, and officers in such cases may be held liable under § 1983 if there is a ‘reason why any of them should question the validity of that order.’” (“It must be clear that defendants cannot circumvent federal prosecution by claiming that they were merely following orders . . . . [T]he government is entitled to prosecute individuals who follow orders to violate federal law, [and] the fact that [defendant] was following the orders of tribal authorities does not immunize him from federal prosecution.”).
WTAF.