reSee.it - Tweets Saved By @CompositeGuy_

CompositeGuy_
Posted - June 17, 2025 at 6:31 PM
Saved - August 16, 2025 at 5:41 AM

@CompositeGuy_ - The Composite Guy

Pakistanis have been expelled from 134 countries. Saudi Arabia alone deported over a 250,00 Pakistanis in the space of five years. UAE has a blanket visa ban on Pakistani men due to their behaviour. Are these Muslim countries racist or is it just sensible immigration policy? https://t.co/1pxUtAuDWx

@TheNewsAgents - The News Agents

"All of this is a gift to the racists." Baroness Casey on how the failure to gather data and to believe survivors has allowed the far-right to exploit the grooming gangs scandal. @maitlis | @lewis_goodall https://t.co/56PkoyM0wh

Video Transcript AI Summary
Data collection is imperfect and needs to be better. There is a “particular problem with Pakistani men and group based child sexual exploitation.” The speaker says the data is imperfect and asks what the report says empirically about this charge. He warns against political football, noting the victims and Pakistani heritage communities. He says the preceding government “did not do a good enough job to collect data to establish ethnicity.” He notes that two very large police forces and Operation Stovewood can collect ethnicity data; “why can't they look at that data” centrally? “There is enough in the audit of looking at these three areas and the disproportionality … to take you to a position of disproportionality.” In Greater Manchester, data shows “live and historic CSX group based” is “significantly disproportionately Asian and Pakistani heritage,” while “live and historic” all child abuse cases are “proportionate to the population, i.e., largely white.”
AI Similar Videos
Full Transcript
Speaker 0: You've got to be utterly responsible with data anyway, but specifically when it's around protected characteristics. Speaker 1: Well, know this is difficult. I think it's really important to to to be precise about this. And I know that the data's imperfect. Of the conclusions of your report is that the data is imperfect, and it needs to be much better. But at the center of this, the politics of this, the political question, which is constantly prosecuted, we've even seen it be prosecuted this morning from Kemi Baidno, is that there is a particular problem with Pakistani men and group based child sexual exploitation. Speaker 0: Has Kemi Bednar said that this morning? Speaker 1: Well, she's what I'm saying is is that she has been out this morning holding a press conference saying that this has been ignored for political reasons for far too long and therefore this is a sort of, you know, it's been part of a cover up and so on. From what you can see, what does your report say empirically about how accurate that charge is, that there is a particular problem and that this problem is centered around Pakistani men? Speaker 0: So I I would just urge enormous caution of the opposition leader making political football out of anything, which, sorry, that's quite a tough thing to say. I just wish people wouldn't because at the heart of it is the victims and then Pakistani heritage communities. The vast majority are law abiding. So what this you know, will you establish facts? Yes, prime minister. I'll establish the facts. The facts are the preceding government did not do a good enough job to collect data to establish ethnicity. And then in recent times, people, the police, MPCC and others, every visit I went to people would say, vast majority of people that commit child sexual exploitation in group based are white, I would say upon what upon what basis if you made that, you know, slide one, slide two, and I was like, and then you've realized they're making that finding on the basis of 30 4% of completion of the data. You can't make that. So people were leaning into a finding that they wanted, which is what I saw in Rotherham, you know, and at one level TIPEX ing out Pakistani on a children's service file, which was probably done in a well meaning way because they'd be worried about sort of racism that flows from that, is actually a gift to racists. I mean, all of this is a gift to the racists. If if if, you know, if good people don't look at difficult issues, bad people will, and even worse people will then exploit them. So, you know, that's my general view difficult things I've been asked to look at in life and this is neither the other. So we established that and then I thought to myself or we thought to ourselves, let's go and look at some of the large police forces where they have been, know, there are sufficient numbers of child sexual exploitation cases of a group based nature for us to look at can they collect ethnicity or not. And yes, they can. So that made me even more cross with the central aspects of this because if you've got two very large police forces and then operation Stovewood in South Yorkshire able to collect that data, why can't I have that data? Why is a previous home secretary or a previous policing minister or the minister for equalities, dare I say it, you know, why can't they look at that data and interrogate it if I just get on a train to West Yorkshire and find it? Speaker 1: But to be clear, does the data such as we have, does it vindicate the idea that has been that has been leveled for for some years now that there is a particular problem among Pakistani men or groups of Pakistani men with group based child sexual exploitation? Speaker 0: There is enough in the audit of looking at these three areas and the disproportionality in those these are fully accurate details to take you to a position of disproportionality. So let's do Greater Manchester for a minute because I asked them to run two separate data sets for me. We've got live and historic child sexual exploitation group based, very accurate, multiple offenders multiple victims it is significantly disproportionately Asian and Pakistani heritage I also asked them to run the data on all child abuse cases live and historic, and it is proportionate to the population, I. E, it's largely white. So that tells you something, which I think is better to understand that than actually data that you can't have nationally.
CompositeGuy_
Posted - September 11, 2023 at 8:44 PM
Saved - January 11, 2024 at 9:50 PM

@CompositeGuy_ - The Composite Guy

[THREAD] We often hear that migration is beneficial for European economies but how true is this claim? In this thread, I will present a comprehensive breakdown of all the evidence from several studies and analysis from across the continent 🧵🔽 https://t.co/nNh13hjJ4X

View Full Interactive Feed